S3, E6
This episode hits all the categories! There are things biblical and unbiblical, things that appear to be error, and some really helpful spots too. Hopefully, this guide can help you sort through the good, the bad, and the made for TV.
Biblical: What We Find in Scripture
Jesus does get visited by two of John's disciples in Matthew 11:2-19 and Luke 7:18-35. Linguistically, it is clear that the disciples of John asked their question to him directly. How the disciples of John came to Jesus isn't recorded in Scripture. We don't know that they came to Peter first. Matthew and Luke just state that John sent some of his disciples; anything more is speculation. When they come to Jesus, he was healing all who came to him, which is what the disciples of Jesus reported back to John. The scene is embellished but follows the biblical accounts. On the particular occasion of this scene, the embellishments reflect a good interpretation of a text that can be difficult to understand.
Unbiblical: What Contradicts Scripture
Mt. 10:5-6, which records Jesus sending out the disciples in twos, records Jesus as saying to his disciples that they should not go to the gentiles or Samaritans. The Decapolis would have been considered outside of the house of Israel; therefore, it is safe to conclude that Jesus never sent two of the disciples there.
Extra-biblical: What Is Made Up but Doesn’t Contradict Scripture
The dream of Pilate's wife in the opening scene is fictional. Scripture does record her having a dream about Jesus, but not until his crucifixion. There is no biblical record that she had more than one dream like this.
The scene where the disciples are sharpening knives and talking about Jesus is fiction. There is no record of such conversation.
Gaius, also Atticus and Quintas, who continually show us in this episode, are fictitious. No one of those names is recorded in the Gospels.
Leander is also a fictional character.
The Bible never records the disciples going to the Decapolis, also called the area of the Gadarenes, without Jesus. The disciples were sent out two by two, but there is almost no record of what the effects of that were. Mark 6:7–13, Matthew 10:1–15, and Luke 9:1–6.
The plot for Zebedee to buy an olive orchard isn't recorded anywhere in Scripture.
The conversation between Tamar, who is a fictional character, and Mary Magdalene was invented for this episode.
In the Gospels, Pilate is only mentioned in connection to the trials and crucifixion of Jesus. This scene with him and Atticus isn't part of the biblical record.
Eden, Peter's wife, remains a fictitious character. While we know that Peter was married, we know nothing of who his wife was.
The statement of Jesus that John is getting impatient isn't really in line with the biblical text. John's imprisonment was most likely a hard and trying time. Certainly, this would have been a discouragement to John, and it is no wonder that he might be wondering if Jesus was the one to come. Additionally, the disciples of John never questioned Jesus about when he will overthrow Rome.
Simon the Zealot's contact with other zealots is fictitious. There is no biblical knowledge that anyone of the Zealots was seeking to kill Simon the Zealot.
Barnaby and Shula are not biblical characters. However, it is widely accepted that Jesus healed all who came to him. This is a picture of that.
There is no biblical record that Peter and his wife lost a baby.
Helpful: What We Might Be Helpful To the Watcher
Jesus touching people. So many who were unclean were untouchable. Jesus wasn't made unclean by the touch of others; they were made clean by his touch.
The response of Shula and Barnaby to the healing of Jesus is helpful. It is much more realistic in its depiction than Peter's response just before this scene, that was more flippant in nature.
Dangerous: Things That Have Been Added That Might Be Dangerous to Accept as Fact
I believe that there is a danger inherent in every episode, and for that reason, I’m including this suggestion in every episode guide. The danger is assuming that the things in the episodes of the Chosen that are not in the Bible are true, part of the biblical record. In order to avoid this danger, I would encourage everyone who watches the Chosen to compare it to the biblical record. IN part, this is because most of what is in each episode of the Chosen is not found in the Bible. There is more speculation here than actual events recorded in the Bible. If you want a harmony of all of the gospels in chronological order to aid this, then I would recommend purchasing a copy of One Perfect Life by John MacArthur. It is a compilation of all of the gospel records in order of the events as best as we can understand.
Regarding the scene with Mary Magdalene and Tamar, the writers of the Chosen have a habit of making some of the most dramatic parts of an episode the things that aren't found in Scripture. Unintentionally, this could lead watchers to believe that the Bible needs help to be interesting. In some way, this presents Scripture as being insufficient.
Anachronisms and Errors: Things that are out of place regarding the time, etc.
One of the people who Jesus heals is mute and carrying a chalkboard with chalk. While chalk existed, though not likely as a writing tool, chalkboards did not. The closest thing to a chalkboard was wax in a frame that could be written in with a stylus and "erased."